DismissedFederal Court of Australia (Full Court)·21 Sept 2021
Federal Court upholds Commissioner's notice seeking LPP details
The Federal Court dismissed an appeal brought against a statutory notice issued by the Commissioner of Taxation requesting information about documents claimed under legal professional privilege. The court ruled that the purpose of the notice was to determine whether to challenge such claims, not to make an actual determination of the claims.
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·30 Aug 2021
Consumer Claim Rejected: Services Failed to Achieve Intended Outcome
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal dismissed an appeal, confirming the original ruling that a service provider was not entitled to payment for services that did not improve a bore's performance due to undisclosed risks.
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·24 Aug 2021
Freedom of Information Decision Upheld by NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
AllowedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·13 Aug 2021
NSW Police Force Exempt from Privacy Laws Due to Administrative Nature of Disclosure
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal decided that the NSW Police Force was exempt from complying with privacy laws because the disclosure of personal information was considered an administrative function.
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·09 Aug 2021
Privacy Complaint Appeal Dismissed by NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·16 July 2021
Travel Agent Not Liable for Refunds Due to Frustration
AllowedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·07 July 2021
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal Sets Aside Decision on Access Application
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·24 June 2021
NSW Appeal Dismissed: Delay and Lack of New Evidence
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·07 May 2021
Convicted inmate's eligibility for victims support denied
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal decided that a convicted inmate was not eligible for victims support because they could not prove they were seriously and permanently injured as a result of the violent incident.
RefusedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·19 Mar 2021
NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal Refuses Leave for Disability Discrimination Complaint
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·11 Mar 2021
Tribunal dismisses appeal over summonses legitimacy
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Occupational Division)·22 Dec 2020
Application Dismissed for Lack of Prosecution in NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
Allowed in PartAdministrative Decisions Tribunal (NSW)·20 Dec 2020
Tribunal Sets Aside Commission's Decision for Exceeding Powers
AllowedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Guardianship Division)·20 Nov 2020
Tribunal Finds Claimant Incapable of Managing Affairs Due to Financial Exploitation
Allowed in PartNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·18 Nov 2020
Partial Success in Appeal Results in Cost Allocation
The claimant appealed certain decisions and won some parts of the appeal but lost others. As a result, the court ordered the respondent to pay the claimant 20% of her costs associated with the appeal.
Allowed in PartFederal Court of Australia·21 Oct 2020
Partial Success for Medical Practitioner Challenging Professional Services Review Decision
A medical a person challenged adverse decisions made against them a person the a company. The Federal Court partially granted their request, finding an error in the decision regarding repayment but upholding other aspects of the decision.
AllowedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Guardianship Division)·12 Aug 2020
Guardianship Order Renewed for Schizophrenia Patient
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Panel)·17 July 2020
Tribunal Rejects Appeal on Child Protection Decisions
The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal dismissed an appeal brought by the claimant regarding decisions on child protection, including the removal of a child and the cancellation of an authorisation. The Tribunal found that it lacked jurisdiction to review these decisions and that the claims were frivolous.
AllowedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Occupational Division)·26 June 2020
Appeal Allowed: Professional Registration Suspension Set Aside
DismissedNSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division)·04 May 2020
Tribunal Confirms Parking Space Levy Assessments
A property owner contested a person assessments on their premises, arguing exemptions should apply. However, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal ruled against them, confirming the levies due to insufficient evidence of exclusive use for exempt purposes.