General & Other
General & Other judgments from Canadian courts and tribunals, with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions.
Unjust Enrichment Claim Dismissed Due to Copyright Act Remedies
Claimant's Request for Lower Vehicle Price Rejected
The claimant asked for a refund because they believed they verbally agreed to a lower price for a vehicle. However, the Civil Resolution Tribunal rejected the request because the claimant could not provide enough evidence to prove the verbal agreement existed.
Consumer Fails to Prove Entitlement to Damages for Returning Faulty Jeans
Contractor Entitled to Payment for Separate Work Items
Wedding Photographer Found Liable for Failing to Deliver Promised Images
A couple hired a photographer to capture their wedding but some images were lost due to inadequate backup procedures. The photographer was found liable for breach of contract and negligence, and ordered to pay damages to the couple.
Federal Court Rejects Motion to Strike Trademark Evidence
Claimant Found Not Responsible for Accident
Cleaning Service Provider Wins Payment for Unreasonable Charges in Small Claims Case
Appeal Dismissed: Competition Act Claim Rejected
The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, upholding the stay of proceedings in favour of arbitration and rejecting the claimant's claim under the Competition Act. The court ruled that since the promotional material clearly stated that fees and taxes remained payable, the claimant's allegations of false or misleading representations were unfounded.
Stolen E-Bikes Claim Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Used Truck Sale Dispute Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
The claimant sued for damages after buying a used truck without an inspection. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the buyer assumed the risk of purchasing without inspection and dismissed the claim.
Supreme Court Rejects Appeal, Allows New Evidence
Federal Court Quashes Invalid Invoice Decision
The Federal Court ruled that an invoice issued to an elected official was invalid because it did not follow the proper procedures outlined in the Financial Administration Law. This decision impacted the official's ability to run for re-election.
Supreme Court Acknowledges New Tort of Coercive Control in Family Relationships
The Supreme Court of Canada has recognized a new legal wrong called 'coercive control' in family relationships. This ruling addresses sustained abuse and control, acknowledging that existing laws do not fully cover these issues.
Personal Injury Claim Against City Dismissed for Late Notice
A person sued the City of Victoria for personal injuries after tripping on a sidewalk. The claim was dismissed because they failed to provide the required notice within two months of the incident, as mandated by the Local Government Act.
Contractor Wins Payment for Completed Civil Engineering Services
A contractor successfully recovered payment for civil engineering services completed, despite the client's objections about unapproved work and deficiencies. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the contractor.