General & Other
General & Other judgments from Canadian courts and tribunals, with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions.
Refund Claim for Editing Services Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Breach of Contract Claim Against Lender Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence
In a recent case, a borrower claimed that a lender's unauthorized credit inquiries caused him to pay a higher interest rate on a car loan. However, the Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claim because the borrower could not provide enough proof that the credit inquiries affected his credit score.
Vehicle Lien Dispute in Nova Scotia Small Claims Court
Tribunal Upholds Insurer's Fault Allocation in Chilliwack Accident
Federal Court Struck Out Judicial Review Application for Lack of Jurisdiction
Federal Court Grants Judicial Review Over Unreasonable Administrative Decision
Claimant Wins Fence Removal and Repair Costs in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case
Decision on Pet Ownership Between Former Partners
Claimant Loses Stone Delivery Dispute at Civil Resolution Tribunal
The claimant ordered stone for her home's exterior and claimed the delivered stone was the wrong color. However, the tribunal ruled that the claimant did not provide enough proof that the stone was incorrect, resulting in a decision in favour of the respondent for payment of the stone and delivery charges.
Accident Responsibility Determination by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Consumer Wins Tooth Damage Case Over Defective Burger
CRT Dismisses Claimant's Accident Claim Due to Res Judicata and Limitation Act
Employment Termination for Misconduct - FPSLREB Decision
The Federal Public Sector Labour Relations and Employment Board ruled to terminate the employment of a supervisor for repeatedly lying about his work. The supervisor claimed his termination was unfair due to his disability, but the board found his dishonesty warranted termination.
Federal Court Approves Settlements for Minor Claimants
Federal Court of Appeal Upholds Employer's Leave Classification and Termination Decisions
Federal Court of Appeal Reinstates Notice of Violation for Animal Overcrowding
The Federal Court of Appeal overturned a Tribunal ruling and reinstated a notice of violation for a company that violated animal welfare regulations by loading hogs in an overcrowded truck. The Court emphasized that liability for such violations is absolute, regardless of the company's knowledge or intentions.
Syphilis Treatment Mandate Request Rejected in Small Claims Court
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a claimant's request for an order mandating syphilis treatment, stating that it lacked the jurisdiction to grant such injunctive relief in small claims disputes.
Lost Baggage Claim Moot After Payment - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In this case, passengers claimed compensation for lost baggage during an international flight. The airline paid the claimed amount, making the claim moot. The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claim as there was no longer a live controversy.
Consumer Wins Full Refund Under BC's Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act
A consumer sued a virtual healthcare provider for a full refund and counselling services. She won a full refund under BC's Business Practices and Consumer Protection Act but not for counselling services, as the provider fulfilled its promise of offering counselling.