Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Used Truck Sale Dispute Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
The claimant sued for damages after buying a used truck without an inspection. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the buyer assumed the risk of purchasing without inspection and dismissed the claim.
Electrical Contractor's Invoice Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence
Civil Resolution Tribunal Rejects Harassment Claims Due to Lack of Evidence
Personal Injury Claim Against City Dismissed for Late Notice
A person sued the City of Victoria for personal injuries after tripping on a sidewalk. The claim was dismissed because they failed to provide the required notice within two months of the incident, as mandated by the Local Government Act.
Contractor Wins Payment for Completed Civil Engineering Services
A contractor successfully recovered payment for civil engineering services completed, despite the client's objections about unapproved work and deficiencies. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the contractor.
Contractor Must Return Deposit for Uncompleted Work
The claimant hired a contractor to pour a concrete driveway and walkways. The contractor did not complete the work and only returned part of the deposit. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled the contractor must return the remaining deposit.
Car Purchase Deposit Non-Refundable: Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
The claimant requested the return of a $1,000 deposit and half of the pre-purchase inspection cost after deciding not to buy a car. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the deposit was non-refundable and dismissed the claim.
Water Leak Claim Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Claimant's Argument on Increased Insurance Premiums Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Refund Ordered for Unperformed Hair Services Due to Illness
Tenant's Noise Nuisance Claim Dismissed for Lack of Evidence
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a tenant's claim for noise nuisance because the tenant did not provide enough evidence to prove that the noise was disturbing and unreasonable.
Subcontractor Wins Partial Payment in BC Small Claims Case
In a small claims case, a subcontractor successfully recovered part of the unpaid work from an employer. The subcontractor provided time sheets and an invoice, proving he had completed the work. The employer claimed to have paid in cash and alleged theft of company tools, but these claims were dismissed.
Rent and Damage Claims Dismissed Due to Lack of Formal Agreement
In a recent Civil Resolution Tribunal case, a tenant (the claimant) tried to get rent and damage compensation from their former roommate (the respondent). The claim was dismissed because there was no formal agreement and the claimant couldn't prove any damage.
Failure to Provide Evidence of Repair Costs Results in Claim Dismissal
Claimant Wins $5,000 for Accounting Services in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case
In a small claims case, the claimant successfully proved that the respondent owed $5,000 for accounting services. The respondent denied hiring the claimant or agreeing to any services. The Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, ordering the respondent to pay the full amount, including interest and fees.
Insurance Voided for Towing Uninsured Trailer
The claimant tried to get compensation for an accident involving an uninsured trailer. The tribunal ruled that towing an uninsured trailer voided her insurance policy, leading to the dismissal of her claims.