Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Claimant Unsuccessful in Seeking Compensation for Defective In-Floor Heating
Roommate Dispute Over Prepaid Rent Refund Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Claimant Wins Unpaid Invoices for Archaeological Services Provided Under Contract
The claimant successfully recovered unpaid invoices for archaeological services provided under a contract. The respondent argued that the claimant had been instructed to stop work, but the Tribunal found in favour of the claimant, ordering payment of $1,859.89 plus interest and costs.
Claimant Wins Waste Disposal Contract Dispute at Civil Resolution Tribunal
Consumer Wins Compensation for Faulty Refrigerator Repair
Claimant's Tilework Quality Allegations Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Consumer Not Entitled to Refund for Breach of Contract Regarding Stone Countertops
Recycling Service Provider Partially Wins Unpaid Invoice Dispute
Shareholder Cannot Sue Corporation: Lack of Standing Dismisses Claim
Wedding Photography Contract Dispute Dismissed in BC Small Claims Court
Contractor Wins Payment for Completed Electrical Work
Claimant Entitled to Payment for Car Parts Under Quantum Meruit - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In a small claims case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal awarded the claimant payment for car parts supplied to the respondent based on quantum meruit principles, considering the market value of the benefit obtained by the respondent.
Insurance Claim Dismissed Due to False Statement About Vehicle Damage
Claimant's Claims Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence - Civil Resolution Tribunal
Payment for Completed Plumbing Work - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In this case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the contractor is entitled to payment for completed plumbing work but not for disputed charges. The homeowner argued that the work was incomplete and of poor quality, but the Tribunal found insufficient evidence to support these claims.
Excessive Speeding Breach Results in $1,000 Penalty for Renter
In a recent case, a renter was fined $1,000 for excessive speeding as stated in their rental agreement. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the rental company, enforcing the penalty.
Small Claims Case: Emergency Chiller Repairs Invoice Upheld
In a recent Small Claims case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal decided to uphold an invoice for emergency repairs to a chiller. The respondent argued that the claimant did not perform regular maintenance, overcharged, and was negligent. However, the Tribunal found that the claimant had proven the necessity and correctness of the repairs, thus upholding the invoice.
Claimant Fails to Prove Negligence in Late Payment Charge
In a small claims case, the claimant tried to get reimbursed for a late payment charge they paid after missing a utility invoice payment. They claimed the respondent was negligent for not updating their mailing address after a fire. However, the Civil Resolution Tribunal found the claimant didn't provide enough proof of negligence and dismissed the claim.
Contractor Entitled to Full Payment for Substantially Completed Work
The dispute was about an unpaid invoice for fireplace installation. The respondents claimed the work was deficient and caused damage. The Tribunal found the respondents failed to prove the work was deficient and ordered them to pay the full invoice amount.