Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law

Contractor Wins Payment for Electrical Work in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case

A contractor successfully recovered payment for electrical work from a client who could not afford to pay, despite the client's financial difficulties. The Tribunal awarded the full amount plus interest and fees.

Settlement Agreement Leads to Refund for Avian TB Treatment Costs

Request to Pause Roommate Dispute During Bankruptcy Denied

Subcontractor Not Obligated to Provide Ongoing Support to Homeowner

In a recent case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that a subcontractor was not obligated to provide ongoing support to a homeowner unless there was an explicit agreement in the contract. The claimant's breach of contract claim was dismissed.

Refunds Granted for Breached Contracts in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case

The claimant asked for refunds for three contracts with the respondent, arguing that the respondent failed to fulfill the contractual obligations. The tribunal reviewed the evidence and granted partial refunds based on the services provided.

Claimant Loses Challenge to Insurer's Full Responsibility Determination in Motor Vehicle Accident

Chargeback Compensation Claim Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal

Claimant's Breach of Contract Claim Dismissed Over Property Condition Issues

The claimant sued the respondents for breaches of contract concerning the condition of a purchased home, including issues with a hot tub, cooktop, and cleaning. The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claim because the claimant did not provide enough evidence to prove the issues existed at the time of sale.

Refund Granted for Breach of Contract - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision

The Civil Resolution Tribunal granted a refund to the claimant for breach of contract regarding the delivery of a couch. The claimant purchased a couch from the respondent, but the couch was delivered late and in the wrong color. The claimant refused the couch and sought a refund and damages. The Tribunal found that the respondent breached the contract and ordered a refund of $2,600, pre-judgment interest, and CRT fees.

Pet Ownership Dispute: Claimant Entitled to Compensation

The Civil Resolution Tribunal decided on a dispute over the ownership of a shared pet dog. The claimant sought compensation for expenses incurred while caring for the dog, which was granted by the court.

Tenant Entitled to Security Deposit Return in Roommate Dispute

In a roommate dispute, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the landlord must return the tenant's security deposit unless proven otherwise. The tribunal found the landlord did not provide sufficient proof to retain the deposit.

Claimant Entitled to Payment for Additional Moving Time

The claimant asked for extra payment for moving services due to unexpected delays. The respondent said the original estimate was final. The tribunal sided with the claimant, saying the extra charges were fair.

Claimant Wins Damages for Incorrect Collision Responsibility Determination

The claimant won damages after proving that the insurance company incorrectly determined responsibility for a collision. The tribunal awarded $150 in damages, interest, and CRT fees.

Tankless Water Heater Claim Rejected by Civil Resolution Tribunal

The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a homeowner's claim for compensation after discovering their new home had a traditional water heater instead of a promised tankless one. The Tribunal ruled that the claimant failed to provide sufficient proof that the seller was obligated to install a tankless water heater.

Claimant's Request for Refund Dismissed by CRT

The claimant asked for a refund because they claimed the credit card charges were unauthorized and the windows were defective. The CRT ruled against the claimant, saying there was no proof of defects and the charges were authorized.

Request for Payment of Legal Services Dismissed by BCCRT

Claimant's Attempt to Recover Damages for Missing Items and Poorly Conditioned Firearms Dismissed

Rent Recovery and Babysitting Compensation Decision

The Tribunal ruled that the claimant was entitled to rent for June and July, but denied compensation for babysitting services. The decision was based on the terms of the tenancy agreement and the evidence presented.

Tenant Wins Breach of Tenancy Agreement Case

Contractor Wins Flooring Payment in Small Claims Case

A contractor successfully recovered payment for flooring work from a subcontractor in a Small Claims case. Despite the subcontractor's claims of unauthorized electrical work and warranty voiding, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the contractor.