Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Contractor Not Liable for Neighbour's Vehicle Damage - Claim Dismissed
A homeowner hired a contractor to mow her lawn. She claimed that the contractor's actions damaged her neighbour's vehicle and sought compensation. However, the Tribunal found that she could not prove the contractor caused the damage or had a legal obligation to pay the neighbour.
Claimant Secures $5,000 Repayment for Personal Loan in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case
The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, ordering the respondent to repay $5,000 of a personal loan. The decision was based on text messages and a bank draft provided by the claimant.
Travel Agent Wins Unpaid Commission Claim
Pet Deposit Dispute Decided in Small Claims BC
Claimant's Defective Chainsaw Claim Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Lawyer wins unpaid legal services claim against client
Employee's Suspension and Termination Claims Dismissed
Contractor Entitled to Payment for Completed Electrical Work Despite Substandard Allegations
Tenant Entitled to Security Deposit Return in Recent Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
Consumer Wins Refund for Non-Refundable Aesthetic Services Package
A consumer bought a non-refundable package for aesthetic services and later asked for a refund. The Tribunal ruled in favour of the consumer, granting a refund under consumer protection laws.
Contractor Ordered to Pay $2,500 for Failing to Install Joist Tape
Claimant Seeks $5,000 for Trade-In Vehicle but Is Denied
Claimant's Request for Damages Dismissed Due to Abandonment of Property
The claimant hired the respondent to create custom leatherwork for his axes. After the work was finished, the claimant did not collect the items promptly, causing the respondent to sell the axes to cover unpaid fees. The tribunal ruled that the claimant abandoned the axes and denied his request for damages.
Tribunal Rules Lack of Jurisdiction in Ticket Purchase Dispute
Claimant Awarded Payment for Water Remediation Services Provided to Respondent
Claimant Wins Damages for Lost Consignment Dress
The claimant successfully recovered $240 in damages for the loss of her consigned wedding dress. The Tribunal ruled that the respondent, as a bailee for reward, did not take proper care of the dress and was liable for its value.
Concrete Cutting Contractor Wins Payment Order Against Company
Claimant's Request for Deductible Refund Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a claimant's request for a partial refund of her insurance deductible. The claimant argued the insurer incorrectly assigned responsibility for an accident, but the tribunal found insufficient evidence to support this claim.