Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Customer Wins Refund for Faulty Refrigerator Repair
A customer successfully obtained a refund of $1,057.85 from a repair service provider after the provider installed the wrong motherboard in her refrigerator, leading to a malfunction.
Claimant Entitled to Payment for Legal Services Rendered - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In a dispute over legal services, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the claimant is entitled to payment for services rendered, regardless of the sale status of the property involved. The respondent's counterclaim was dismissed.
Employer Claims Against Former Employee Partially Allowed
Tenant Wins Security Deposit Return in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case
Claimant Loses Small Claims Case Over Incorrect Insurance Liability Decision
In a recent small claims case, a claimant tried to get compensation from an insurance company due to an incorrect liability assessment following a motor vehicle accident. The Civil Resolution Tribunal reviewed the evidence and concluded that the insurer's decision was correct, dismissing the claimant's request for compensation.
Contractor Entitled to Payment Upon Substantial Completion - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
Claimant's Request for Legal Services Refund Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
CRT Cannot Decide Vehicle ACV Disputes - Small Claims Ruling
Service Provider Fails to Prove Work Completion in Small Claims Case
In a recent small claims case, a service provider failed to prove the completion of work described in their invoices. The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claim due to a lack of supporting evidence beyond the invoices themselves.
Supplier Entitled to Payment for Goods Supplied Under Contract
Claimant Denied Refund for Towing Fees Due to Lack of Evidence
The claimant asked for a refund of $520.88 in towing and storage fees, citing financial hardship and inadequate signage. The tribunal ruled against the claimant, stating that the municipality's actions were lawful under its bylaws.
Employer's Claim for Loan Repayment Dismissed
Recliner Defect Entitles Claimant to Full Refund - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that a recliner's foam was defective under the Sale of Goods Act, entitling the claimant to a full refund of $647.93.
Negligence Claim Against Contractor Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Contractor Wins Full Payment for Exterior Cleaning Services
A contractor successfully recovered the full amount owed for exterior cleaning services from a client who had not paid. The tribunal ordered the client to pay the full invoice, interest, and tribunal fees.
Claimant Loses Case Over Water Damage in Strata Building
In a strata building, the Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claimant's claim for water damage, ruling that the claimant failed to prove the respondent's responsibility for the damage.
Contractor's Invoice Claim Dismissed Due to Lack of Clear Agreement
Pool Liner Installation Caused Leaks: Contractor Held Liable
Enforcement of Easement Agreement - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
Claimant Wins Partial Payment for Boiler Repairs
A contractor sued a homeowner for payment of boiler repairs and servicing. The homeowner disputed the charges, claiming the contractor performed unauthorized work. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the homeowner owed the contractor $1,319.85 for the authorized repairs, plus interest and CRT fees.