Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Employment Status and Termination Notice Decision
Car Rental Damage Claim Ruled in favour of Tenant - Civil Resolution Tribunal
Claimant Cannot Challenge Invoice Without Contractual Standing
The claimant asked the tribunal to lower an invoice for moving services but was told he couldn't do this because he didn't have a direct contract with the service provider.
Claimant's Injury Claim Dismissed Due to Lack of Unreasonable Risk
Settlement Agreement Enforced in Text Message Dispute
The Tribunal enforced a settlement agreement reached via text message between former romantic partners, awarding the claimant $930 for flights and property damage.
Used Vehicle Defect Claims Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a claimant's allegations of vehicle defects and misrepresentations because the claimant failed to provide sufficient evidence and the 'buyer beware' principle applied.
Decision on Unpaid Cleaning Invoices - Civil Resolution Tribunal
The claimant requested payment for cleaning services and site orientations. The respondents argued that some services were incomplete or not agreed upon. The tribunal ruled that the respondents owe $1,609.50 for unpaid invoices but dismissed the claim for the site orientation.
Request for Vehicle Compensation Due to Accident Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a claimant's request for compensation for a vehicle damaged in an accident. The claimant argued the insurer delayed settling the claim, leading to the vehicle being scrapped. However, the tribunal found insufficient evidence to support the claimant's request for $3,000.
Claimant Wins Payment for Bookkeeping and Payroll Services
In a Small Claims case, the claimant successfully recovered payment for bookkeeping and payroll services from the respondent. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, ordering the respondent to pay a total of $2,133.39, including interest and fees.
Tenant Successfully Recovers Damage and Pet Deposits
In a recent decision, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that a tenant successfully recovered her damage and pet deposits from the landlord. The landlord claimed that the tenant had caused various damages, but the Tribunal found insufficient evidence to support these claims.
Claim for Unpaid Fees After Motion Capture Shoot Cancellation
The claimant was hired for a motion capture shoot but the shoot was cancelled. The claimant argued for payment under the contract, claiming $3,284.08 in fees and travel costs. The Tribunal found an implied term requiring reasonable notice of cancellation and awarded $3,175 in damages and fees.
Wig Quality Claim Rejected in Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In a recent Civil Resolution Tribunal case, a customer requested a refund for a wig she believed was of poor quality and did not fit properly. The Tribunal found that the customer failed to provide enough evidence to support her claim and dismissed it.
Insurance Coverage Claim for Vehicle Damage Dismissed
Decision on Payment for Professional Engineering Services in Small Claims
A professional engineer sought payment for services rendered under a contract. The client disputed the final invoice, arguing the charges were unreasonable and overinflated. The Tribunal ruled that the engineer had not sufficiently justified the charges and ordered partial payment.
Sectional Couch Manufacturing Defects Lead to Full Refund - Civil Resolution Tribunal
Medical Malpractice Claim Dismissed for Being Out of Time
Claimant's breach of contract claims dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Claimant's Flight Change Claim Rejected in Small Claims Case
Claimant Entitled to Share of Returned Venue Deposit After Joint Rental Cancellation
Tenant Entitled to Produce Credit Despite Not Starting Farming
In a commercial lease dispute, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the tenant was entitled to a produce credit of $1,000, even though the tenant did not start farming operations. The decision was based on the terms of the lease agreement.