Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Refund Awarded for Breach of Verbal Contract
The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, who successfully argued that the respondent breached a verbal contract by failing to deliver well testing results in a timely manner. The claimant was awarded a refund of $1,470.85.
Respondent Held Personally Liable for Service Provider's Invoice
In a recent case, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that a respondent who contracted with a service provider without disclosing their connection to a corporation was personally liable for the resulting invoice. The decision underscores the necessity of transparency in contractual agreements.
Claimant Wins Compensation for Used Clothing Underpayments in Civil Resolution Tribunal Case
Unpaid Wages Claim Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence
The Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed a worker's claim for unpaid wages because the worker could not provide proof of an employment contract or detailed work records. The employer argued the worker was hired by a subcontractor, not directly by them.
Claimant Wins Shipping Container Accessibility Dispute
The claimant bought a shipping container from the respondent but couldn't pick it up because it wasn't accessible as promised. The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, rescinding the contract and ordering the respondent to return the deposit and pay for the shipping company's failed delivery attempt.
Claim for Trailer Damage Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Supplier Must Refund Buyer for Undelivered Custom Sign
Claimant Fails to Prove Damage by Respondent's Technician in Small Claims Case
Refund and Damages Claim Dismissed by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Successful Claim for Gas Line Damage - Civil Resolution Tribunal
The claimant sued the respondent for damaging a gas line. The respondent admitted to the damage but argued the repair costs were too high. The tribunal ruled the respondent was liable but only awarded part of the claimed repair costs.
Roommate dispute over rent and costs - Civil Resolution Tribunal ruling
Two former roommates had a dispute over rent and associated costs after one roommate breached their agreement. The Civil Resolution Tribunal found the claimant partially successful and ordered the respondent to pay $554.09, including damages, interest, and fees.
Water Damage Claim Rejected by Civil Resolution Tribunal
Consumer's Claim Against Credit Card Company Dismissed
The claimant argued that a credit card company violated the Business Practices Consumer Protection Act by engaging in deceptive practices. The tribunal found no evidence supporting the claim and dismissed the case.
Landscaping Contract Dispute Decided by Civil Resolution Tribunal
In this case, a contractor sought payment for completed landscaping work, but the client disputed the quality of the work and claimed deficiencies. The Civil Resolution Tribunal reviewed the evidence and determined that the contractor was entitled to payment, minus deductions for proven deficiencies.
Professional Negligence Claim Against Dental Clinic Dismissed Due to Lack of Expert Evidence
A patient claimed that a dental clinic failed to properly fix his dentures, leading to additional dental expenses. However, the Civil Resolution Tribunal dismissed the claim due to insufficient evidence.
Claimant Entitled to Partial Payment for Home Design Services
In a dispute over payment for home design and drafting services, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled the claimant is entitled to partial payment for services rendered, considering the respondent's agreement to pay for the services and the lack of detailed time records.
Claimant Wins Misrepresentation Case Against Used Car Seller in BC Small Claims
Client Must Pay for Legal Services Rendered According to Retainer Agreement
In a family law matter, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the respondent must pay the claimant for legal services rendered according to their retainer agreement, dismissing allegations of unpreparedness and negligence without expert evidence.
Subcontractor Recovers Payment from Contractor but Not Homeowner
A subcontractor successfully recovered payment for restoration work from the main contractor but failed to prove unjust enrichment against the homeowner. The case highlights the importance of direct contracts in such disputes.