Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims case law
Judgments from the Civil Resolution Tribunal (British Columbia) — Small Claims with a plain-English summary, the legal holding and frequently asked questions. The original content is public and official; the summaries and analysis are produced by VadeLab's technology.
Wedding Deposit Refund Claim Dismissed for Being Out of Time
Claimant's Lawn Service Claim Dismissed for Lack of Evidence
Civil Resolution Tribunal Refuses to Resolve Mobile Phone Service Agreement Dispute
The Civil Resolution Tribunal refused to resolve a dispute about a mobile phone service agreement, stating that such cases should be handled by the CRTC, not the Civil Resolution Tribunal.
Claimant Partially Successful in Personal Property Dispute
The claimant sued the respondent for stealing personal property, including antique furniture, dirtbikes, and a computer. The claimant wanted $4,900 in compensation. However, the Tribunal ruled that the claimant did not prove ownership of the antique furniture and one of the dirtbikes. The claimant was only awarded $800 for the computer.
Negligent Misrepresentation Claim Against Property Manager Dismissed
Subcontractor Entitled to Reduced Payment for Deficient Work
Lease Agreement Dispute Ruled in favour of Lessor
The Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that a lessee who failed to make payments and returned a destroyed vehicle is liable for the outstanding balance within the CRT's monetary limit. The claimant, who leased a car to the respondent, was awarded $5,000.
Claimant Proves Negligence in Gas Line Damage
The claimant successfully proved that the respondent was negligent in damaging its gas line. However, the tribunal found that some of the repair costs claimed by the claimant were unreasonable and reduced the amount accordingly.
Claimant Fails to Prove Liability for Towed Vehicle - Civil Resolution Tribunal Decision
In a dispute over a towed vehicle, the Civil Resolution Tribunal ruled that the respondent, who was an involuntary bailee, was not liable for the removal of the unauthorized vehicle from his property. The claimant failed to prove the respondent's responsibility for the losses incurred.
Contractor Entitled to Payment for Substantially Completed Work
Small Claims Dispute Dismissed Due to Lack of Evidence
Claimant Wins Damages for Water Connection Damage
The claimant successfully sued the respondents for damages caused by trespassing on their property during driveway construction. The Tribunal ruled in favour of the claimant, ordering the respondents to pay for the damages.
Employer Successfully Recovers Overpaid Wages and Laptop Costs
In a recent case, an employer successfully recovered overpaid wages and the cost of a laptop and accessories from an employee. The Civil Resolution Tribunal found that the employee was unjustly enriched by the overpayment and failed to return the company property.
Tenant Wins Double Security Deposit After Landlord's Delay
Claimant Wins Partial Damages for Chaise Lounge Damage
Tenant Wins Deposit Refund After Landlord Fails to Provide Clean Room
Tenant Partially Succeeds in Damages Claim Against Landlord
Executor Claims Credit Refund Successfully
An executor of a deceased person successfully claimed a credit refund from a respondent in a small claims case. However, the claim for stress damages and time spent on the claim was dismissed.